Co-op vs. Condo in New York: The Legal Differences
A co-op and a condo can look identical from the hallway. Legally they are different things to own, with different approvals, costs, taxes, and risks.
The difference between a co-op and a condo in New York is what you actually own. In a condo you own real property: your unit, by deed. In a co-op you own shares in a corporation that owns the building, along with a lease that lets you live in your apartment. Almost every practical difference between the two follows from that.
What do you own?
Condominium. You receive a deed to your unit, together with an undivided interest in the building's common elements, such as the lobby, roof, and hallways. It is real property, like a house.
Cooperative. You receive stock in the corporation that owns the building and a proprietary lease for your apartment. You are a shareholder and a tenant at once. For most legal purposes your interest is treated as personal property, not real estate.
Can the board turn you down?
This is the difference buyers feel most.
Co-op. The board of directors must approve every purchaser. It can ask for detailed financial information, interview you, and reject the application, generally without giving a reason. Courts review board decisions under the business judgment rule and will rarely second-guess one made in good faith and within the board's authority. That deference is not unlimited: a court can step in where a board acts in bad faith, outside its authority, or for a discriminatory reason.
There is a firm limit. A board may not reject a buyer on a ground prohibited by the anti-discrimination laws, including the New York State and New York City Human Rights Laws.
Timing has also changed in New York City. A local law that took effect in 2026 sets deadlines for the boards of larger co-ops to acknowledge a completed application and to decide it. It does not require a board to give its reasons.
Condo. A condominium board ordinarily cannot reject a buyer. Under most condominium by-laws it has only a right of first refusal: the right to buy the unit itself on the same terms. Boards rarely use it.
A contract to buy a co-op is normally conditioned on board approval. The buyer has to apply in good faith and cooperate with the process. If the board turns down a buyer who did, the buyer is ordinarily entitled to the down payment back.
How does the financing differ?
A condo purchase is financed with a mortgage on real property. A co-op purchase is financed with a loan secured by your shares and your lease.
That has a real cost consequence in New York. Mortgage recording tax applies to a condo mortgage and does not apply to a co-op loan. On a sizable loan in New York City, that difference runs to thousands of dollars.
Co-op boards also commonly set their own financing rules, such as a minimum down payment well above what a bank would require. Condos generally do not.
Which taxes apply?
More of them overlap than buyers expect:
- New York State transfer tax applies to both.
- The "mansion tax" on residential purchases of $1 million or more applies to both.
- New York City's Real Property Transfer Tax applies to both.
- Mortgage recording tax applies to condos only.
For the rates and who usually pays, see closing costs in New York.
What do you pay each month?
Co-op. You pay maintenance to the corporation. It covers your share of the building's real estate taxes, any mortgage on the building itself, and operating costs. Shareholders can generally deduct their share of the building's real estate taxes and mortgage interest on their own tax returns.
Condo. You pay common charges to the condominium for operating costs, and you receive your own real estate tax bill for your unit.
Because a co-op's maintenance includes taxes and the building's mortgage, comparing a maintenance figure directly with a condo's common charges will mislead you. Compare total monthly cost.
What is a flip tax?
Many co-ops charge a transfer fee when an apartment is sold, usually paid by the seller. It goes to the building, not to the government. A co-op may impose one only if its governing documents, such as the proprietary lease or the offering plan, provide for it (Business Corporation Law § 501(c)). That is where you will find the amount and who pays. Ask about it before you make an offer or list your apartment.
What happens if an owner stops paying?
Condo. Unpaid common charges become a lien on the unit, which the board can foreclose (Real Property Law § 339-z). That lien comes behind real estate taxes and a first mortgage.
Co-op. The corporation's remedy comes from the proprietary lease. It can terminate the lease and cancel or sell the shares.
In both, the financial health of the building is your concern too, since the other owners share its costs. Your attorney should review the building's financial statements, its board minutes, and, in a co-op, the terms of the underlying mortgage.
What about subletting and renovations?
Co-ops generally keep tighter control. Many limit how long and how often a shareholder may sublet, and require board approval for subtenants and for alterations. Condos are usually more flexible, subject to the by-laws. If you may want to rent the apartment out, read the rules before you buy.
Does the seller have to give a disclosure statement?
Not in either case. New York's Property Condition Disclosure Act, which requires a disclosure form on the sale of a one- to four-family house, does not cover condominium units or co-op apartments. Your own inspection and your attorney's review of the building's records matter that much more.
Which is right for you?
Neither is better in the abstract. A co-op gives the building more say over who lives there and how apartments are used. A condo generally costs more at closing if you are financing, because of the mortgage recording tax, and gives the owner more freedom.
If you are buying or selling a co-op or a condo in New York City or on Long Island, call the office. For more, see Real Estate and why an accepted offer is not a contract.
Attorney Advertising. These posts are general information about New York law, not legal advice about your situation, and reading them does not create an attorney–client relationship. Laws and deadlines change and depend on the facts; each post speaks as of its date. See the full Disclaimer & Disclosure Statement.
