Do I Have a Medical Malpractice Case in New York?
A bad result is not the same as malpractice. Here is what New York law requires a patient to prove, and how to tell whether your situation is worth a lawyer's review.
You may have a medical malpractice case in New York if a doctor, nurse, or hospital departed from accepted standards of care and that departure caused you a real injury. Both parts are required. A bad outcome is not enough, and neither is a mistake that did no harm.
That is the short answer. Here is what each part means in practice.
What do you have to prove?
A patient who brings a malpractice case in New York must show two things:
- A departure from accepted practice. The provider did something a reasonably careful provider would not have done, or failed to do something one would have.
- Causation. That departure was a cause of the injury.
The patient has the burden of proving both, by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning that it is more likely than not.
There must also be an injury serious enough to justify the case. These cases are expensive and slow, and a real error that caused only brief or minor harm is rarely worth pursuing.
Is a bad result malpractice?
Not by itself. Medicine carries risk, and complications occur when everyone does everything right.
New York law also protects a doctor's judgment. A physician who chooses among medically acceptable alternatives, after a careful examination, is not liable simply because the choice turned out badly. The law draws a line between a judgment call and a failure to do what the standard of care required.
The useful question is not "did something go wrong?" but "what should have been done differently, and would it have changed the result?"
Why do these cases need a medical expert?
Jurors are not doctors. In almost every case, a medical expert must explain what the standard of care was, how it was breached, and how the breach caused the harm.
New York builds this in from the start. A malpractice complaint must be accompanied by a certificate stating that the attorney has consulted with a physician and concluded there is a reasonable basis for the case (CPLR 3012-a). No responsible lawyer files without that review.
There is a narrow exception for errors that speak for themselves. If a surgical instrument or sponge is left inside a patient, a jury may be permitted to infer negligence from the event itself.
What if the problem was a delay in diagnosis?
Delayed and missed diagnoses are among the most common malpractice claims, and causation is usually where they are decided. It is not enough to show that the condition should have been caught sooner. The delay must have made a difference: a worse outcome, more extensive treatment, or a lost chance of a better result.
For a missed cancer diagnosis, New York has a special rule on timing. See how long you have to sue for a missed cancer diagnosis.
Who is responsible, the doctor or the hospital?
Often both are named, but the rules differ.
A hospital is generally responsible for the negligence of its own employees, such as nurses, residents, and staff physicians. It is generally not responsible for a private physician whom the patient chose and who merely has privileges there.
There is an important exception. When a patient comes to the emergency room looking to the hospital for care, and not to a particular doctor, the hospital can be held responsible for the physicians it supplies, even if they are technically independent contractors.
Identifying every responsible provider early matters, because each may have different insurance and, for public hospitals, a different deadline.
What if I was partly at fault?
A patient's own conduct, such as not following instructions or missing follow-up appointments, does not bar the claim. It reduces the recovery in proportion to the patient's share of the fault (CPLR 1411).
How long do I have?
Generally two years and six months from the act or omission, or from the end of a continuous course of treatment for the same condition (CPLR 214-a).
Three situations are different:
- Public hospitals. A claim against a hospital run by a city, a county, or a public benefit corporation generally requires a notice of claim within 90 days and a lawsuit within one year and 90 days.
- Children. The time is generally extended while the patient is a minor, but in malpractice cases never beyond ten years from the act or omission (CPLR 208).
- Missed cancer and foreign objects. Each has its own discovery rule.
Signs your situation is worth a review
- A condition was diagnosed late, and earlier tests or complaints were there to be acted on
- A surgery ended with an injury to a part of the body that was not being operated on
- You were given the wrong medication or the wrong dose
- You were sent home from an emergency room and came back much sicker
- A provider or a later treating doctor expressed surprise at what was done
- A child was injured during labor or delivery
None of these proves malpractice. Each is a reason to have the records looked at.
What happens when you call
A first conversation costs nothing. If the facts warrant it, the records are gathered and reviewed with a physician, and you are told plainly whether there is a case. For what that involves, see getting your medical records, and what a malpractice lawyer costs.
If you are wondering whether you have a medical malpractice case, call the office. For more, see Medical Malpractice.
Attorney Advertising. These posts are general information about New York law, not legal advice about your situation, and reading them does not create an attorney–client relationship. Laws and deadlines change and depend on the facts; each post speaks as of its date. See the full Disclaimer & Disclosure Statement.
